The Globe and Mail: The federal government is backing away from setting a timeline to introduce legislation that would declare First Nations policing an essential service, but at least one regional chief hopes to see it this spring.
Ghislain Picard, a member of the Assembly of First Nations executive, says it has been fighting for improvements to First Nations policing on two fronts: securing better funding for existing services and helping to draft new legislation. “We’ve been talking about this for years,” said Picard, one of the leads on justice and policing issues for the national advocacy organization that represents more than 600 First Nations.
Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino told The Canadian Press last December that the government hoped to table a bill in 2023. This week, however, a press secretary for the minister backed away from any timeline, saying “It is too early to say when the legislation will be tabled.”
In September 2022, Mendicino told reporters he would “work around the clock” to table a bill that fall. That came two years after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau promised to “accelerate work on First Nations policing, including legislating it as an essential service.”
Picard said he and others working on the issue remain “very much committed to see legislation hopefully before the House rises in June.” “We’re still very much on that target, from our end.”
Mendicino’s director of communications said Tuesday that the legislation is a “major element” of its efforts to expand policing on First Nations. “This work is well underway and includes several unique elements that make it difficult to provide an exact time frame. Most significantly, this bill is being co-developed (with) the Assembly of First Nations as an equal partner,” Alexander Cohen said in a written statement.
“Furthermore, it involves an area of shared federal-provincial jurisdiction, and as such requires more co-ordination between orders of government. That said, we are not waiting for legislation to take action.” Cohen pointed to millions of dollars dedicated in previous budgets for First Nations policing, and ongoing work with individual communities and tribal councils on efforts to bolster community safety.
The funding of First Nations police services is the subject of a human rights complaint recently launched by nine police services in Ontario. At the heart of the complaint is an allegation that the 1991 program Ottawa uses to provide the funding is inadequate, leaving police services strapped for staff, equipment and other resources. The program is cost-shared with provinces.
The complaint alleges that “deliberate and wilful” underfunding amounts to discrimination on the part of the federal government. It has garnered the support of the association advocating for all 36 First Nations police services in Canada. Picard said such a complaint was foreseeable given the long-standing concerns from chiefs. “They’ve been complaining about this program and its shortcomings from Day 1.”
An internal review of the program released last year by the Public Safety Department found that its “finite amount” dedicated in its budget leads to an underfunding of policing agreements, which creates ongoing challenges for services.
The federal government is still trying to determine the scope of the essential service legislation. Asked Tuesday whether he has seen any drafts or wording, Picard said: “We’re not there yet.” “This is where the issue of co-development is key,” he said, adding that it is a complex process. “We’re there, we have the federal government, and then where are the other jurisdictions, where is their role in all of this?”
Picard was attending a special assembly meeting in Ottawa, where chiefs were to discuss the federal government’s implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. He said the spirit of that declaration is informing work on the policing bill.
STEPHANIE TAYLOR: OTTAWA, THE CANADIAN PRESS